Is Galaxy Watch 4 Classic worth buying?

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Smartwatches

Is Galaxy Watch 4 Classic worth buying?

(Image credit: Future)

The Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 lineup gives shoppers a few design options depending on what best suits their lifestyle. Whether you want a big-screened device that still looks like a traditional timepiece or a sleek and small smartwatch, there’s a Galaxy Watch 4 for you. Your style preferences could result in spending over $100 more than other customers, though.

If you’ve read our Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 review or our guide to the Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 vs. Galaxy Watch 4 Classic, you’ll know the two models have essentially identical internals, which start at $249.99 and $349.99 for the 40mm and 42mm sizes, respectively. 

  • See the best smartwatches right now
  • Exynos 2200 allegedly crushes A14 Bionic — it’s great news for Galaxy S22
  • Plus: Fossil Gen 6 could be a great Galaxy Watch 4 rival but there's a big catch

The larger sizes of each model (44mm for Galaxy Watch 4 and 46mm for Galaxy Watch 4 Classic) have slightly higher battery capacity than the smaller sizes, but that’s about it in terms of technical specs. 

Instead, all the differences lay on the outside. Though Samsung dropped the ‘Active’ branding, the standard Galaxy Watch 4 is slim and sporty-looking while the ‘Classic’ version carries on the iconic characteristics of last year’s Samsung Galaxy Watch 3. 

Better yet, this year’s Classic version starts at a lower price than the Galaxy Watch 3. You can find the previous-generation smartwatch on sale right now, but it cost $399.99 at launch. Sounds like a score, right? Perhaps to some, but after spending time with both versions of Samsung’s new smartwatches, I'm not convinced the Classic option is worth the money. 

The rotating bezel is fun, but Samsung is holding onto it the same way your dad is holding on to your family's old VCR player. Except your dad probably isn't expecting anyone to pay $100 for it.

In my video review of the Galaxy Watch 4 smartwatches (opens in new tab) shared to YouTube, I joked how the $100 premium for the Galaxy Watch 4 Classic just gets you a fidget spinner. I meant that in respect to the fan-favorite rotating bezel that first debuted on the original Samsung Galaxy Watch, I promise.

But my sarcasm didn’t seem to land with some commenters, who pointed out the Galaxy Watch 4 Classic’s premium also includes a stainless steel case, rather than an aluminum one. Thanks, I know. I just didn't think most people care about materials as much as functionality. 

I’m not saying $349.99 for stainless steel wrist candy isn’t enticing. For comparison, the Apple Watch 6 in stainless steel starts at $799.99. Still, if you really care about luxury materials, what are you doing buying a Samsung smartwatch over a designer timepiece? The Galaxy Watch 4 Classic doesn't even include leather straps. Those cost extra, and don't come in the contoured shape like the silicone ones included in the box.  

The Galaxy Watch 4 Classic gives me dad vibes, and that's the best way I can describe my opinion. It doesn't quite make the fashion statement Samsung attempted. While the bezel is fun, it's like Samsung is holding onto the mechanism the same way your dad is holding on to your family's old VCR player. Except your dad probably isn't expecting anyone to pay $100 for it.

Look, if you're attracted to the chunkier look of the Galaxy Watch 4 Classic, don't let me stop you. It has all the best Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 Wear OS features, so spend your money how you please. 

But if you wanted to hear from someone who used both the standard Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 and Galaxy Watch 4 Classic whether the price for the latter version lives up to the higher price, it's doesn't. For the lower price, slimmer shape and modern design, the $249.99 Galaxy Watch 4 is the ultimate steal. 

  • Next up: Samsung Galaxy S22 early leaks and what we want to see
  • How to set up the Samsung Galaxy Watch 4
  • How to use Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 to measure body composition

Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.

Kate Kozuch is an editor at Tom’s Guide covering smartwatches, TVs and everything smart-home related. Kate also appears on Fox News to talk tech trends and runs the Tom's Guide TikTok account (opens in new tab), which you should be following. When she’s not filming tech videos, you can find her on an exercise bike, mastering the NYT Crossword or channeling her inner celebrity chef. 

How long should Galaxy Watch 4 Classic last?

Samsung estimates the Galaxy Watch 4 will last 40 hours on average and that's largely in keeping with what I've experienced in the sense that it usually lasts between 24 and 48 hours with moderate use.

Should I buy Galaxy Watch 4 or Classic?

It depends on your priorities, but for most people, we'd recommend the regular Galaxy Watch 4. It's $100 cheaper than the Watch 4 Classic at MSRP, and all you're missing out on is the steel case and physical rotating bezel.

Which is best watch 4 or watch 4 Classic?

The only difference between the Watch4 Classic and the Watch4 is the design. The Watch4 Classic has a stainless steel watch case, which makes this smartwatch slightly heavier and more robust than the Watch4. The Classic edition also has a rotating bezel.

Should I get Galaxy Watch 4 or wait for 5?

For current Galaxy Watch 4 owners, there are a few reasons to upgrade; the Watch 5 has a more durable screen, better battery life, improved sleep tracking, and a Skin Temperature sensor that will eventually work. While these features may not be a big deal for some, for others, these are the features we've been craving.